The Virtual EngineerLife Experiences in the Virtual Engineering World

I will point out the obvious and state that 2009 was a brutal year for many. Lots of organizations doing a bit of soul searching and digging in to try and reinvent themselves. Hopefully!

Those of us in the CAE or CAD industry are no different. Even though business has been slower than normal, the expectations have never been higher. It is interesting that many organizations went quiet for many months, but they are beginning to show their faces and have some big, big plans. Let’s take a look at some of the big topics of 2009.

Direct Modeling Wars

This has been one of the bigger topics to hit the MCAD market in five years. The boys at SpaceClaim broke onto the market preaching the concept as the next thing since sliced bread. Interestingly, they took a fair amount of criticism from the “traditional” parametric fanatics. But 2009, has seen all of the major MCAD vendors jump on the push/pull bandwagon. Some have gone all in and some have integrated direct modeling on top of the parametric based system.

Autodesk has Fusion.

Siemens has Synchronous Technology

PTC has CoCreate

SpaceClaim takes it to the next level with multi-touch.

The reality is that I don’t believe we have seen even the beginning of where this technology will take the engineering community. I don’t think anyone questions that there are obvious benefits to being able to sculpt and modify geometry from anywhere. The concept is still fairly new and a bit too disruptive for mass adoption. I suspect that the next year we will see some big things in this arena.

Upfront Simulation

A topic that has been near and dear to my heart for the last 12 years. I have been a believer from the beginning. Seems so simple. Leverage your existing 3D model, simulate upfront early in the design phase repetitively, until the optimal design is obtained and then physically test it to validate. Reduces the design cycle, reduces failure in the field etc. But this concept is still slow to be adopted.

We have seen a number of big advancements in this field this year. Both Solid Edge and Inventor have embedded FEA solutions. The bigger news is that both Siemens and Autodesk have much broader plans when it comes to simulation, well beyond a simple embedded solution. They are both a number of years behind Pro/Mechanica and the boys at SolidWorks, but clearly will expose this concept to a whole pool of new engineers.

CFD is now becoming a household name. It used to be the scary term that only the geekiest of the geeks was able to discuss. But we are seeing that it is the fastest growing market in CAE. ANSYS confirmed it and transformed themselves from a hardcore structural simulation company into a CFD house with the acquisition of Fluent.

On the opposite end of the spectrum, we at CFdesign, are changing the way people interact with CFD. We continue to target design engineers and have proven time and time again that CFD can help reduce physical prototypes, save failures in the field and increase innovation. But, more importantly, it can be driven by design folks and doesn’t have to be an analyst only tool. The introduction of the multi-scenario design study environment opens the flood gates to what design engineers can do with CFD.

Goliath Acquisitions

Feels like a giant love fest that everyone is buying everyone. What used to be a fairly broad landscape of small software companies is now narrowing itself down to a few behemoths. ANSYS has established themselves as the one stop shop simulation powerhouse. So far so good with regards to their position in the market (stock price-wise), but they have a long rode ahead. Keeping the dedicated user base of each acquisition happy is no simple feat. This extends way beyond the stock price. If you are not careful, you risk pissing off your dedicated user base and are now a bloated has-been. Time will tell.

Autodesk is also making a serious move into simulation with the acquisition of Algor and Moldflow. Interesting combination to say the least– complete ends of the spectrum. But in perfect Autodesk fashion, nothing happens without a well calculated plan. From my perspective, the integration seems slow, but talking to some of the higher ups at Autodesk, they feel to be “right on track”. After speaking with some of the dedicated users at #AU2009, I’d say their assessment isn’t far off.

Dassault appears to be playing a chess game of late. They are making very slow, but allegedly strategic moves. I am referring to DS as a whole. I think the boys at SW are always raising the bar. But the bigger V6 initiative has me perplexed. Conceptually, I think I get it and think it has some potential, but I’ll be damned if I can explain exactly what it is. I’d post a You Tube video that explains it, but couldn’t find one that made sense. If you are listening DS, I’d be happy to do a review of V6, but need someone to explain it to me. I’m sure its me.

Apple jumps into the Game

Tons and tons of buzz about who supports the Apple platform. Initially, I thought it was a bunch of hype, but seems like everyone is getting into the game. Macs were everywhere at #AU2009, lots of buzz at PLM World and I’m anxious to see the reaction at #SWW2010.

I have to admit, I am skeptical. I think Apple puts out some nice products and they are really riding the wave pretty well. But the engineering community is a whole different breed, they tend to be slow to become fanboys. Sure, there are exceptions, but the price of the hardware for Apple may be its downfall in mass adoption in engineering companies. I predict that we will see slow (perhaps steady) adoption by the early adopter/power user types, that’s about it for now.

Cloudy Forecast

Seems like everyone is gearing up for the “cloud”. It is on everyone’s radar, but few have jumped into the deep end. As I reported from #AU2009, Carl Bass was as direct as any exec I have seen on where it plays into the big picture.

Seems logical that we will see this as one of the faster growing trends in CAE. The big question will be where will it stick. Data management and collaboration seem like no-brainers. But, being on the simulation side of the house, I suspect computing power will be the biggest bang for the buck. The challenge here is user experience. Everyone will agree that running on a cluster in the cloud is faster, but the implementation of it sucks right now. Bandwidth is finally becoming reliable, but thinking of having “power” in the sky isn’t part of the mainstream workflow. I think this will change big time in the near future.

Mobile Engineering

No doubt the iphone has changed the way people think of mobile computing. It seemed like the thing to do in 2009, to rush out and create an iphone app for your product. Dassault did it. Autodesk did it.

Initially, I thought it was fad over function. But, I think it will play more and more of a role in our engineering lives. Probably not in the form that it exists today, but the fact is people are attached to their phones more now than ever. They will no doubt be a natural extension in the CAE space.

The potential is endless. Obviously, the sketching tools and accessing drawings will be a standard. But interacting with simulation will be critical. Models will only be getting larger and the more the computing is being pushed to the cloud, the more the need to monitor, interact and publish the raw data will grow.

Social Media is here to stay

Yes, even engineers are tweeting and blogging and even facebooking. Seems very non-engineering of us to be so social. But, I am convinced that the adoption of the tools will continue to grow. Maybe, not the tools as we see them today, but there isn’t a more diverse, opinionated, knowledge craving group than engineers.

PTC went so far to coin the phrase, “Social Product Development“. I know there are quite a number of eyes rolling, but I don’t think they are far off the mark. Conceptually, that is, implementation will be key.

As many of you know, I am a big fan of twitter, facebook, linkedin, flickr and you tube (see side bar for links). It is more than a fad for me, its part of my personal and professional life. The key is simply being plugged in and connected with those around me. The challenge is wading through the bullshit when it comes to social media. Many are overwhelmed, don’t know where to start and couldn’t be bothered. What do I say to them? Take the time, expand your comfort zone and see what is out there. You might be surprised that there are tools out there that can actually help you stay current and communicate with a world that you would otherwise not know exists. Check out Jeff’s @lifeupfront’s take on it.

Conclusion

This is only a small slice of what happened in 2009. The exciting part is that many of these topics are fairly new in our world. CAE has been on the steady climb over the last few years with performance and user experience. These topics are still growing leaps and bounds, but they are now just expected. The real game changers are the ones that are thinking outside the box, beyond our comfort zones. Personally, I am perfectly ok with that.